2012 HomeWorld
Middletown High School Orchestra
Theatre Guild's "Wittenberg"
Home > Blogs > Arts and Entertainment > Archives > 2008 > September > 15 > Entry
“Music Man” doesn’t quite ring up the sale
The object here isn’t to propose that Jason Collins lacks musical theater ability. He’s a talented song and dance man in the style of a George M. Cohan.
But Harold Hill? Spellbinder, smooth-talking operator and leading man? He’s not quite right for that part, just as his stage wardrobe seemed distractingly ill fitting Saturday night, Sept. 13, during opening weekend of the Dayton Playhouse’s production of Meredith Willson’s “The Music Man.”
It’s a good show. It’s a big show. Director Amy Brown’s cast of well over 50 is well coached and many of the musical numbers are very well done.
But even though it takes place in River City, Iowa, in 1912, the show isn’t called “River City.”
Nor is it called “Marian the Librarian.” If it was, it would need to be pointed out that Kelly Pekar, who plays the leading female role, is a bit young for the part, especially opposite Collins. She is gifted vocally and dramatically, even proving her mettle submitting to a kiss from sleazy anvil peddler Charlie Cowell (John Bukowsky). Her delivery of “Will I Ever Tell You?” and “Till There Was You” were lovely.
It’s called “The Music Man.” Hill, and therefore Collins, is the focus from the opening scene on the railroad car where his notoriety has preceded him among other salesmen.
One critic’s critiques about casting aside, there were no complaints from the sold-out audience. It’s also accurate to report that members of the barbershop quartet that croons “Ice Cream,” “Sincere” and “Lida Rose” got the most enthusiastic applause.
Others featured included: Renee Franck-Reed as Mrs. Paroo, Philip Smyth as Marcellus (who meshed nicely with Collins on “The Sadder But Wiser Girl”), Roger Watson as Mayor Shinn and Becki Norgaard as Eulalie.
The onstage orchestra conducted by Nancy Perrin blended amicably with the singers. The set is by Chris Harmon. Annette Looper’s choreography was simple and effective.
“Music Man” will continue through Sept. 28 at 1301 E. Siebenthaler Ave. Times are 8 p.m. Fridays and Saturdays and 2 p.m. Sundays. Tickets are $12 to $16. Call (937) 424-8477.
Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Review, Theater
Comments